Thank you for your interest in a custom creation by Hollycake House!

 There is a minimum of 10 days notice for all custom work, based on availability. We are a small shop and do book up quickly on weekends/holidays. Please plan in advance for all custom orders!

If you are looking for a basic cake with a special message, please order via Bakery Order Online

We offer custom creations for weddings, anniversaries, birthdays (smash cakes), graduations,  baby showers, and other special events.

All items are fully vegan, but can also be gluten free, soy free, canola free, sugar free, nut free, or allergy free. Contact us below for your custom creation.


Each cake is unique and therefore pricing is dependent on flavors, complexity of design and size. See the chart below for a list of base prices for commonly requested cake sizes. Price will increase from the base price depending on the above factors.


Cake servings and sizing can be tricky since there is not one universal way to cut a cake. The sizes below are estimations on serving sizes. For a cake cutting & serving guide click here.

All cake flavors, fillings and frostings are fully vegan. All can be made gluten free. For soy free, sugar free, nut free, or other allergies - please call for options.


When requesting a custom cake it is wise to have a flavor profile in mind. You may not have a definitive plan, but having an idea of your flavor likes and dislikes is helpful to create the perfect flavor combination for you (see our chart below for flavor ideas).

If you have an idea or image of the style/design of cake please send it along with your request. Check out our Gallery page for ideas.


Custom Baked Goods:

We can also accommodate large orders of pastries/baked goods for parties and events. 

If you are in need of a custom dessert/pastry tray, please fill out the form below.


Custom cakes may only be ordered by calling 585-310-7728, via email at or by filling out the contact form below.


Prior to contacting please have the following information ready:

  • Your event date and time

  • Servings needed

  • Flavor profile or likes and dislikes (see chart below for ideas)

  • Style/Design with images if possible

Custom Cake Inquiry